TEASER!! Sister Wives Season 20 Tell All Part 4 – The CATFISH Scandal

The long-running emotional fault lines of Sister Wives are about to crack wide open once again, as Season 20’s Tell-All Part 4 revisits one of the most painful and controversial chapters in the Brown family’s history: Meri Brown’s infamous catfishing scandal. While many viewers may wonder why the family is digging up old wounds, this final installment makes it clear that the past is not just history—it is the foundation of everything that ultimately fell apart.

This episode serves as a deep dive into u nresolved trauma, fractured trust, and long-simmering resentments that continue to shape the family’s present. At the center of it all are Robyn Brown, Kody Brown, and Meri Brown, who finally confront the lingering questions surrounding the online relationship that shook their plural marriage to its core. According to the family, these events were not minor bumps in the road; they were turning points that sent the family spiraling in a direction from which they never truly recovered.

From the very start, the Tell-All frames the catfishing scandal as one of several key moments that pushed the family toward collapse. Longtime fans will remember that tension had existed well before Meri’s scandal. Even earlier conflicts—such as Janelle entering the family and initially planning to marry Kody on Meri’s birthday—are referenced as symbolic of deeper issues around respect, boundaries, and emotional neglect. These moments, layered over time, created fractures that were never properly healed.

Now, years later, the catfishing incident is back under the microscope. Some members of the family have described Meri’s online involvement as an emotional affair, while others insist it was the result of manipulation during an extremely vulnerable period in her life. Kody and Robyn have repeatedly suggested that this situation permanently damaged their ability to trust Meri, a claim that the Tell-All directly challenges by forcing all parties to explain their roles and motivations.

In a preview discussed by Us Weekly, Robyn Brown makes it clear that she is standing firm in her version of events. During the upcoming episode, host Sukanya “Suki” Krishnan presses Robyn with a pointed question: given everything that has happened, does she believe Meri has legitimate reasons not to trust her? Robyn’s response is immediate and unwavering. She insists that Meri has no grounds for distrust and that she has always supported her.

Robyn argues that during Meri’s darkest days—particularly while the family was living in Las Vegas—she was one of the few people who recognized how deeply Meri was struggling. She recalls noticing Meri’s emotional withdrawal and increased online engagement, which included conversations about music, flowers, and flirtation. According to Robyn, these interactions raised red flags that compelled her to intervene, not out of malice, but concern.

Robyn explains that she urged Kody to step in and reconnect with Meri emotionally, believing that their fractured relationship had left Meri vulnerable to outside attention. She admits that she involved herself in their marriage dynamic at the time, but frames her actions as an attempt to help them repair their bond rather than undermine it. In her mind, she was acting as a protector, not a betrayer.

However, Meri has long seen the situation differently. When the scandal first became public in 2015, Meri revealed that the person she believed she was communicating with online turned out to be a woman posing as a man. She insisted that the relationship never extended beyond digital conversations and maintained that she never met the individual in real life. Still, she acknowledged deep regret for allowing herself to become emotionally involved.

At the time, Meri released a heartfelt statement explaining that she had been going through an intensely painful period and was drawn into a situation that spiraled out of control. She expressed hope that by sharing her experience, she could help others avoid similar emotional traps. Yet despite her vulnerability, the fallout was brutal—both publicly and privately.

One of Meri’s most painful claims has been that Robyn made the situation worse by relaying information back to Kody, further eroding whatever trust remained between them. This alleged breach is a major reason Meri says she struggled to feel safe confiding in Robyn afterward. The Tell-All finally brings this accusation into the open, forcing Robyn to address it head-on.

Robyn does not deny that she communicated with both Meri and Kody during that time. In fact, she emphasizes that she was intentionally transparent, believing honesty was the best way to prevent further harm. She recalls confronting Meri directly, questioning why she was engaging in such conversations and warning her that she appeared to be taken advantage of emotionally. From Robyn’s perspective, remaining silent would have been far more damaging.

Still, Robyn acknowledges that others are entitled to interpret her actions differently. She tells Suki that if Meri—or anyone else—believes she crossed a line, she can accept that criticism. What she refuses to accept is the idea that her intentions were malicious. She insists that every decision she made came from a place of concern and loyalty.

Adding fuel to the fire, Kody Brown appears to support Robyn’s version of events. In footage from the Tell-All trailer, Kody erupts emotionally, declaring that if one of his wives is involved in an affair—emotional or otherwise—it is absolutely his business. His reaction underscores how deeply betrayed he felt at the time and explains why the catfishing scandal became such a defining rupture in his relationship with Meri.

The episode also revisits the broader context surrounding the scandal, including the legal divorce between Kody and Meri in 2014. That decision allowed Kody to legally marry Robyn and adopt her three children from a previous relationship. While Kody and Meri remained spiritually married afterward, many fans now see that moment as the beginning of the end for their union.

Their spiritual marriage finally ended in January 2023, when they announced their separation in a joint statement. By then, Christine and Janelle had also left the marriage, confirming that the once-united plural family had completely unraveled. In hindsight, the Tell-All suggests that the catfishing scandal was less an isolated mistake and more a symptom of emotional neglect and systemic dysfunction within the family.

As Tell-All Part 4 unfolds, viewers are reminded that unresolved pain doesn’t fade just because time passes. Instead, it lingers beneath the surface, influencing decisions, reshaping relationships, and fueling resentment. This episode doesn’t promise neat resolutions, but it does offer raw honesty—and perhaps a final reckoning.

With emotions running high and long-held narratives colliding, this final chapter of the Season 20 Tell-All is set to be one of the most intense yet. Sister Wives Season 20 Tell-All Part 4 airs February 1 at 9:00 p.m. CST on TLC, and it’s guaranteed to leave fans debating where the blame truly lies long after the credits roll.