VIEWERS IN SHOCK!!! Corriedale viewers ‘amazed’ to realise killer Theo starred in iconic 00s series

Promo picture of Theo in Coronation Street as he stands by a grey brick wall
Corriedale viewers recognised Theo Silverton star James Cartwright for a totally different role (Picture: ITV)

Coronation Street fans have been aware of Theo Silverton’s vile abuse of Todd Grimshaw (Gareth Pierce) for a while now, but his dastardly behaviour came as a shock to viewers of Corriedale – especially the ones who recognised actor James Cartwright from his previous high-profile role.

For months now, Theo has been manipulating, gaslighting and controlling boyfriend Todd, with his abuse turning violent on multiple occasions.

At the end of last week, vicar Billy Mayhew (Daniel Brocklebank) finally learnt the truth about Todd’s ordeal, after seeing his bruises. After finding video footage of Theo abusing Todd, Billy managed to convince him to leave.

However, their plan to sneak away from Debbie Webster (Sue Devaney) and Ronnie Bailey’s (Vinta Morgan) wedding early hit a snag when Theo caught on, and joined them on the minibus.

Over the course of their journey, it dawned on Theo that Billy knew the truth about what had been going on behind closed doors, leaving both Billy and Todd in a dangerous situation.

Theo looking at terrified Todd with a sinister expression and his had on the headrest of Todd's chair as they sit beside each other in a minibus in Coronation Street
Theo has been abusing Todd Grimshaw for months (Picture: ITV)
Billy looking worried while sitting behind the wheel of a minibus in Corriedale
Theo had to silence Billy Mayhew (Picture: ITV)

When the minibus got caught up in the multi-vehicle pile-up that kicked off Corriedale, Billy ended up trapped inside. With the bus on fire, he raced to free himself, finally managing to unbuckle his seatbelt.

Horrifyingly, Theo had crawled back into the bus and buckled Billy back in, destroying his hopes of making it out alive. Sure enough, the vehicle exploded moments later with the vicar trapped inside.

This came as a huge shock to many, including Twitter/X user Wanda, who was horrified that a recognisable face from her childhood was now a killer.

There was also recognition from countless other fans, who recognised James from his time on CBBC smash hit children’s series The Story Of Tracy Beaker, which is based on the book of the same name by Jacqueline Wilson.

James Cartwright arrives for the premiere of Corriedale, a combined episode of Coronation Street and Emmerdale which airs in January, at the National Science and Media Museum, Bradford. Picture date: Tuesday December 16, 2025. PA Photo. Photo credit should read: Danny Lawson/PA Wire
James joined Coronation Street last year (Picture: Danny Lawson/PA Wire)

They were absolutely baffled that James had played such vastly different characters in his career, with some refusing to believe it was the same person.