Welcome back, soap lovers, to Drama Digest—the channel where we peel back the emotional, heart-stopping, and outrageous layers of daytime storytelling. Today, we’re diving into a storyline that blends tribute with wild speculation, grief with hope, and reality with the supernatural twists only Days of Our Lives can deliver. Grab your tissues and buckle up—because we’re about to explore one of the most breathtaking theories shaking Salem to its core: Dr. Rolf may resurrect John Black.

Yes, that John Black—the enigmatic hero who has battled kidnappings, demonic forces, doppelgängers, crime syndicates, and, more than once, death itself. And now, whispers echo across the fandom that it’s not Stefano returning from the grave this time… but John.

To understand the weight of this possibility, we must reflect on the man behind the character. Drake Hogestyn, beloved by fans for nearly four decades, tragically passed away on September 28th, 2024, after a quiet but fierce battle with pancreatic cancer. His death shook the soap world, the entertainment industry, and millions of viewers who felt like they lost a family member. But in Salem—where science, magic, and madness collide—death isn’t a closed door. Instead, it becomes the spark for a new chapter.

And that brings us to the twist that has fans gasping: Could Dr. Wilhelm Rolf bring John back?

Before we get to the resurrection theories, let’s revisit the legacy that makes this speculation so explosive.

Drake Hogestyn wasn’t born into the glamour of TV stardom. Raised in Fort Wayne, Indiana, he spent his early life heading toward sports and science. A standout college baseball player studying microbiology, he might have ended up in a lab coat or a major league dugout. But fate intervened, and after minor league baseball ended, he stepped onto the stage—and history was made. In 1986, he became John Black, and daytime television has never been the same.

John wasn’t introduced as your typical leading man. He arrived in Salem wrapped in bandages, nameless, memory-less, known only as “The Pawn”—a human puppet hidden deep in Stefano DiMera’s sinister schemes. As layers of his identity peeled away, John transformed into everything fans adore: a super-spy, a priest (yes, really), a mercenary, a family man, and the eternal soulmate of Marlena Evans.

For nearly 40 years, Hogestyn embodied John with a unique mix of strength, vulnerability, and charm. The intense blue-eyed stare, the gravel-soft voice, the wounded hero vibe—it all became iconic. He brought the same kindness off-screen: devoted husband, proud father, tireless supporter of charities, and a gentle spirit known for greeting fans like old friends.

But while on screen John triumphed over every enemy, in real life Hogestyn fought a battle few knew about. Pancreatic cancer—one of the deadliest, most aggressive cancers—claimed his life far too soon. Fans were devastated. Co-stars poured out tributes. Social media flooded with clips of John’s greatest Salem moments—saving Marlena from the devil, fighting Stefano in underground lairs, reuniting with his children, surviving explosions, and defying death repeatedly.

And that’s the heart of the conversation now:
If any character could come back from the dead one more time, it’s John Black. 

Especially when the mad scientist responsible for half the miracles—and nightmares—in Salem is involved.

Enter Dr. Wilhelm Rolf.

If there’s any character in the DOOL universe who treats death like an optional inconvenience, it’s Rolf. With his bizarre labs, shimmering vials, lightning-charged machines, and morally questionable genius, Rolf has resurrected Stefano, brainwashed half of Salem, transferred consciousness, and revived characters who were reduced to ashes.

And rumor has it… he’s working on something new.

Word is circulating that the writers are toying with a jaw-dropping story:
Rolf has created a revolutionary serum capable of reanimating dead tissue, combining rare Amazonian flora with micro-nanotechnology.

Imagine the visual:
A fog-laden Salem night.
Rolf sneaks into a secret facility where John’s cryogenically preserved body rests.
He injects the glowing serum as machines whir and sparks crackle.
Marlena waits in agony, hands trembling, whispering, “Come back to me, John…”

And then—
A twitch.
A breath.
A heartbeat.

Or perhaps something far darker.

This theory exploded after fans noticed a peculiar detail in Drake Hogestyn’s final episode: the heavy bandages, the reduced physical presence, and the use of a stunt double. These choices may have been born from necessity—but they also leave a perfect opening. Did we actually see John die? Is there room for a switch? A secret move? A Rolf-engineered plan?

Let’s be honest—this is Days of Our Lives. They LOVE ambiguity.

Looking beyond the storyline logic, the fandom is divided, passionately.

About 65% of viewers are begging for a resurrection:

• “John is the soul of Salem—don’t let him go.”
• “He deserves a final reunion, not an off-screen ending.”

They want closure, romance, emotional payoff, and a continuation of John’s storylines with Orpheus, Brady, Belle, Paul, Eric, and Marlena.

But 35% disagree:

• “Let Drake rest. Don’t cheapen his death with a fantasy plot.”
• “The tribute was beautiful. Leave it at that.”

Both sides make compelling arguments—but one thing is certain: the writers know how much John means to this show, and they’ve rewritten reality before to keep characters alive.

So how could this resurrection actually happen?

Picture this storyline unfolding in cinematic detail:

The episodes begin with Marlena plagued by dreams of John calling out to her, whispering, “Doc… I’m not gone.”
Meanwhile, Rolf acquires the final ingredient needed for his serum—a glowing exotic flower rumored to hold the “essence of life.”
At John’s memorial, the entire Brady-Black-Evans clan gathers, but the somber event is shattered by a mysterious message slipped under Marlena’s seat:
“Death is only a doorway.”

Suddenly, bodies disappear from the morgue. Strange lights flash from an abandoned DiMera lab. Rolf is spotted in Salem after being presumed missing.

And then the unthinkable:
John wakes up—but not as the man he once was.

No memories.
No identity.
Or worse… carrying a dark passenger.

This leads to a sprawling arc about identity, science, ethics, grief, and love. Marlena must choose whether to fight for the man she loves—even if he comes back changed—or accept that some miracles come with consequences.

Writers could even tie the plot to other soap universes, global conspiracies, medical emergencies, or corporate wars over Rolf’s serum.
Think about the tension if EJ DiMera learns about the formula.
Or if Orpheus tries to weaponize it.
Or if John—half resurrected, half fractured—holds the key to saving Salem from a looming crisis.

Of course, this is all speculation, but it’s the kind of speculation that keeps Days of Our Lives alive after 60 years. The blend of heartfelt tribute and outrageous drama is exactly what makes this show unforgettable.

Drake Hogestyn is irreplaceable, and nothing could ever replicate his influence or the beauty he brought to John Black. But stories allow characters to live forever—sometimes literally.

Whether Rolf succeeds, fails, or unleashes chaos, one truth remains:
John Black will always be a legend.
And in Salem, legends never stay buried.

Do you think the writers should bring John back?
Is a resurrection fitting—or too far?
Let me know your thoughts!

---